Chapter Five of NextText explores the idea of making and remaking history. In the introduction to the chapter, Kress and Winkle write:
...the field of history is wider and more complex; it includes biography, autobiography, graphic narrative, and texts written from competing theoretical perspectives (for example, feminist, conservative, libertarian, etc.). At base, all histories relate and interpret information about the past. Interpretation is critical because once historians move beyond simply providing a chronology of dates, they begin to shape our understanding of events by creating a narrative, a causal chain...History, then, is not a static field; rather, it is an ongoing dialogue with the past that is always informed by the present.Discuss how three of the following Chapter Five selections illustrate the idea that history is subjective and constantly changing.
- Clayborne Carson, "Malcolm X" (405)
- Sarah Vowell, "1776: A Musical about the Declaration of Independence" (413)
- "Frontlines: Dispatches from U.S. Soldiers in Iraq" (420)
- John Hodgman, "The States, Their Nicknames and Mottoes, and Other Facts Critical to Safe Travel" (432)
- Anne Scott MacLeod, "Rewriting History" (440)
- Ian Mortimer, "Revisionism Revisited" (450)
- Robert Brent Toplin, "Judging Cinematic History" (457)
- Lynn Neary, "The Mixed Reviews of the Museum of the American Indian" (464)
- John Leo, "Googling the Future" (471)
- "A Portfolio of Graphic Novels" (476)